- Cases, Defamation
Chai Rachawat: Criticized against Prime Minister
Defendant
Case Status
Case Started
Complainant / Plaintiff
Table of Content
Chai Rachawat was charged with defamation after he criticized the Prime Minister strongly on his personal facebook. The critism was made after the Prime Minister delivered a speech in Mongolia.
Defendant Background
Mr. Somchai Katanyutanan, aka Chai Ratchawat, is a senior political cartoonist at Thairath newspaper. His recognized works are the daily published political cartoon series "Phuyai Ma Kab Thung Ma Moen."
Offense
Allegation
The day after the Prime Minister delivered her speech at the Ministerial Conference of the Community of Democracies in Mongolia, in which the speech referred to Thai military coup d'etat in 2006, the defendant posted a message on his personal facebook account that "Please understand that prostitutes are not evil women because they just sell their bodies, but an evil woman sells the nation." The caption ran with a picture of the Prime Minister and therefore resulted in the charge of defamation.
Circumstance of Arrest
Trial Observation
Black Case
Court
Additional Info
Reference
http://www.bangkokpost.com/lite/topstories/349529/politics-likely-motive-i-thai-rath-attack
http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/politics/348280/pm-sues-cartoonist-over-evil-woman-comment/page-3/
http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/PM-files-lawsuit-against-Chai-30205381.html
http://www.khaosod.co.th/en/view_newsonline.php?newsid=TVRNMk56UTRNelkyTlE9PQ==%C2%A7ionid=
http://www.bangkokpost.com/print/349443/
http://thaipoliticalprisoners.wordpress.com/2013/04/30/at-last-yingluck-stands-up/
29 April 2013
At the 7th Ministerial Conference of the Community of Democracies in Mongolia, Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra delivered a speech stating that people are striving for democracy, and at the same time, many people are sacrificing their blood and lives in order to protect and build a democracy. She claimed that, in 1997, a new Constitution related to Participatory Democracy was created in Thailand, and consequently many people thought an era of coups d'etat had finally come to an end. Nevertheless, a rightfully elected government of former Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra, her brother, was overthrown. The coup not only made her family suffer, but it also meant Thailand lost its international credibility. Moreover, she mentioned that the crackdown on the red-shirt movement caused many innocent victims shot dead by snipers, and the existence of the anti-democracy regime allowed some Thai senators to be appointed without an election.
30 April 2013
Chai Ratchawat posted a message on his personal facebook account "Please understand that prostitutes are not evil women because they just sell their bodies but an evil woman sells the nation” along with a picture of the Prime Minister.
2 May 2013
At 1:00pm, the Red-shirts led by Mrs. Ladawan Wongsriwong, former Minister of the Prime Minister's Office, rallied in front of Thairath head office and laid down a funeral wreath in order to protest this particular case. The Red-shirts demanded Thairath to take action against Chai
Ratchawat and also demanded the newspaper to refrain from making statements amounted to violation of journalistic ethics. Furthermore, the Red-shirts announced that if there was no apology from the cartoonist, they would reassemble again on May 7, 2013.
3 May 2013
Mr. Suranand Vejjajiva said that the Prime Minister was willing to listen to criticism, but critics should be careful by not using inappropriate words to insult female gender. He added that the legal counsel would consider every word and criticism. If they found that any personal defamation was made, they would consider whether they would take legal action.
In the same day, Ms. Yingluck Shinawatra, the Prime Minister, instructed her legal team to file a complaint to the police against Chai Ratchawat.
11 May 2013
At 3:00am, Pol Capt Ukrit Klaptao, an inquiry official at Bang Sue police station, was alerted that there was an attack at Vacharaphol Co.Ltd, the office of Thairath newspaper. Bombs and firecrackers were thrown at the front-gate security booth. The booth’s window glass was shattered while police found a fragment of a small green bomb and also found cherry-bomb fireworks under the counter. According to the investigation, a security guard who witnessed the incident said that at around 3:20pm there were four men on two motorcycles parked outside the gate of the Thairath’s office. Getting off the motorcycles, two of them headed to the security booth and shouted. Suddenly, they threw two iron petanque balls to break the glass then followed with the fireworks, which caused a big boom, then all the attackers immediately fled away. The motive of the incident remains ambiguous and there was no proof that it was related to the case of Chai Ratchawat. However, the incident happened during the feud, so many critics tried to link them.
21 May 2013
Metropolitan Police Bureau deputy chief Pol Maj-GenAnuchai Lekbamrung, the chief investigator of the case, said his team met and decided that the allegation against
Somchai Katanyutanont or Chai Ratchawat was founded. Chai faced three counts: insulting a government official during an official event; defaming another person via the media; and violating the Computer-Related Crimes Act, which prohibits posting defamatory comments against others on the Internet. Police issued a summons for the cartoonist to give a statement at 10am on June 5.
June 4, 2013
Pol Col Sukhun Prommayon, deputy chief of Metropolitan Police division 1, revealed that the defendant’s lawyer made a requirement to postpone the interrogation for 30 days reasoning that preparation of documents as well as evidences for the lawsuit was needed.
23 June 2013
The defendant posted a message on his personal facebook account saying that on the day he had to appear to the police, he wished that there would be no accident or obstacle aimed at him. Recently, a high ranking police officer had threatened him through the media, saying if he failed to report himself to the police; an arrest warrant would be issued. The defendant said that over several decades he has been working as a cartoonist or he even used to live under eras of military dictatorship, and no one had ever threatened him both publicly and he did personally like it. Moreover, he insisted that he was ready to fight in this case.
24 June 2013
The defendant reported to Metropolitan Police Division 1 to testify himself and acknowledge charges filed by Norawich Lalaeng, Prime Minister’s lawyer, which are the charges of having defamed a government official while she was carrying her duty and having defamed a person via advertisement as well as violating the Computer Crime Act at Dusit police station.